Started by @bradtuck
Greatest quarterback of all time
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better Super Bowl
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better wide receiver
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better value draft pick
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better arm talent
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better Super Bowl halftime show
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better football dynasty
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better running style
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better tight end
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better head coach
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better pure arm strength
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better historic rivalry
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better safety in NFL history
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
More athletic quarterback
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
More controversial NFL call
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better all-time defense
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better running back
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better NFL uniform
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
More iconic play
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Better Hail Mary throw
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better NFL fanbase
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @colem
Tougher cold-weather fans
Pick a side to see the split
Started by @bradtuck
Better tailgate culture
Pick a side to see the split
Showing 23 of 23 debates