Tom Brady
66% of votes
VS
Joe Montana
34% of votes
VS
Cast your vote to see what the world thinks
Reward Milestones
$1
Earned1,000 votes
$10
Earned10,000 votes
$100
Earned50,000 votes
Arguments
6Want to join the debate?
Log in to join the debatePinned
B
bradtuckŠī¸1d ago
Team Tom Brady
7 Super Bowl rings. SEVEN. Brady played at an MVP level until age 45. Montana is great but the gap in longevity is enormous.
J
juliemcvŠī¸1d ago
Hot take: if Montana had Belichick for 20 years, he might have 8 or 9 rings. Coaching matters more than people admit.
D
delray22đ1d ago
Team Tom Brady
Both are legends but Brady winning with completely different rosters and coaches over 20 years tips the scale. Montana always had elite supporting casts.
H
henrikbđ1d ago
Team Joe Montana
Montana played in a different era with much less passer protection. If he played today with these rules, he'd be even more dominant.
K
kev_27â1d ago
Team Tom Brady
The 28-3 comeback against the Falcons is the single greatest performance in sports history. You can't be the GOAT without that moment.
C
colemâ1d ago
Team Joe Montana
Montana never threw an interception in a Super Bowl. 4-0 with a perfect passer rating in the big game. Brady choked a few times before the comebacks.
B
Started by
bradtuck
Created
1 day ago
More in this category
View all âđ American FootballđĨ59.2K votes
Started by @bradtuck
VS
Better Super Bowl
Pick a side to see the split
đ American FootballđĨ55.7K votes
Started by @colem
VS
Better wide receiver
Pick a side to see the split
đ American FootballđĨ48.1K votes
Started by @colem
VS
Better value draft pick
Pick a side to see the split